PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 4340
Joseph Lazar, Referee
AWARD N0. 13
CASE NO. 13
PARTIES ) BROTHERHOOD OF MAINTENANCE OF WAY EMPLOYES
TO_ ) _ _ _- vs
DISPUE )BURLINGTON NORTHERN RAILROAD COMPANY =
STATEMENT
OF CLAIM: _-Claim in behalf of J. J. Short that he be returned
to service with payment for all time lost and that
the charges be removed from his service record as
a result of
his
dismissal April 11, 1988.
FINDINGS: _ The Board, on consideration of the whole record
and all the evidence, finds that the parties
herein are Carrier and Employee within the meaning of the Railway
Labor Act, as amended, that this Board is duly constituted by Agree
ment dated April 10, 1987, that it has jurisdiction of the parties
and the subject matter, and that, pursuant to the Agreement dated
April 10, 1987, oral hearing by the parties, including Claimant,
has been duly waived.
On May 4, 1982, Claimant had an on-the-job injury,
and from July 6, 1983 until April 11, 1988, he was on Carrier-granted
medical leave of absence. The Carrier dismissed the Claimant on
April 11, 1988, following his medical release to return to work, and
on June 10, 1988, the Carrier held a formal investigation charging
the Claimant with failure to report the on-the-job injury of May 4,
1982.
Between May 4, 1982 and April 11, 1988, almost
six years elapsed, and in this period the Carrier had knowledge of
the on-the-job injury,and took no action charging the Claimant with
rules violation for failure to report the on-the-job injury of May
4, 1982.
During the period from May 4, 1982 to April 11,
1988, there were a number of changes in supervisory personnel, key
witnesses became unavailable, memories faded, records became unavailable, and circumstances and conditions changed. June 10, 1988 was
too late to hold a fair and impartial hearing. See National Railroad
Adjustment Board, Third Division Awards Nos. 14504 and 14505 (Dorsey),
and National Railroad Adjustment Board, Third Division Award No.
24701 (Klaus).
i
AWARD NO. 13 (P. 2)
CASE NO. 13
A W A R D
1. The Carrier is in violation of the Agreement.
2. The claim is sustained.
Order: The Carrier shall implement this Award within thirty days
of date of Award.
JOSEPH LAZAR, CHAIRMAN AND NEUTRAL MEMBER
DATED: October 30, 1989
43yb-~