PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 4370
BROTHERHOOD OF MAINTENANCE OF WAY EMPLOYES
and
BURLINGTON NORTHERN RAILROAD COMPANY
AWARD NO. 48
Case No. 48
STATEMENT OF CLAIM
1. That the Carrier violated the provisions of the
current Agreement when it disqualified Group III Operator
Mr. Larry Tyler.
2. That the Carrier restore Claimant's Group III
Operator rights with all seniority and all other rights
unimpaired and compensated for all wage loss suffered.
F I N D I N G S
Following an investigative hearing, the Claimant received the
following notice from the Carrier:
Effective this date you are hereby disqualified as
a Group III Operator for continued violation
of
Rules 50,
52, 62 and 63 . . . when you failed to properly secure
workheads of Chase tamper, and they bled down and hit
crossing on Feb. 20., 1991, at M.P. 188.5, L.S. 485.
The incident in question resulted in $2,000 damage to the
Tamper.
Review of the record indicates support for the Carrier s
conclusion that the Claimant was at fault in the incident. As to
the resulting disqualification, the Carrier took into account the
Claimant's previous record, which shows a number of offenses,
including a 15-day suspension in reference to a machine collision
the previous year.
The organization takes particular exception to the citation of
"continued" in the notice of disqualification. The Board does not
find this improper. As stated in Third Division Award No. 21835:
Determination of guilt as to the alleged offense in
question is confined to evidence developed at the
investigative hearing. It is, however, entirely
reasonable and fitting for the Carrier to weigh the past
record of the employe in assessing the degree of penalty.
A W A R D
Claim denied.
<-~yoil.
HERBERT L. MARX, Jr., Neutral Referee
NEW YORK, NY
DATED: November 2, 1992