PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 4373
PARTIES SOUTHERN PACIFIC TRANSPORTATION COMPANY )
(EASTERN LINES) )
AWARD N0. 18
TO AND )
CASE N0. 15
BROTHERHOOD OF MAINTENANCE OF WAY )
DISPUTE EMPLOYEES )
STATEMENT OF CLAIM:
i. Carrier violated the effective agreement when Houston _
Division B&B Foreman J. J. Weeks was unjustly dismissed
from service.
2. Claimant Weeks shall now be paid for all time lost due to 20
working days suspension commencing August 10, 1987, and con
tinuing through September 8, 1987, and with charge letter of
. August 7, 1987, removed from his personal record.
HISTORY OF DISPUTE:
Claimant was suspended from service for twenty working days for his
failure to promptly report a personal injury to an employee under his supervision. Claimant requested and was granted a hearing under provisions of the
Agreement. Subsequent to the hearing, Claimant was notified that he was 'found
to be in violation of Rule E and that his suspension was upheld.
The Organization grieved the discipline. As the dispute remains unresolved, it is before this Board for final and binding determination.
1313
~fo,
l 8
_ p _
FINDINGS:
The Board upon the whole record and all the evidence finds that the
employees and the Carrier are employees and Carrier within the meaning of the
Railway Labor Act, as amended, 45 U.S.C. b§151 et sea. The Board also finds it
has-jurisdiction to decide the dispute in this case. The Board further finds
that the parties to the dispute, including Claimant, were given due notice of
the hearing in this case.
Claimant contends that he attempted, unsuccessfully, to contact his super
visor to report the personal injury. It is unrefuted that Claimant did place
the accident report on his supervisor's desk prior to going home. The Board
agrees with the Carrier's contention that Claimant should have contacted someone
in authority when he determined that his supervisor was unavailable. While we
believe the Carrier was within its prerogative to assess Claimant a suspension,
we think the length was excessive. We believe, under the circumstances of this
case, Claimant should have received no more than a five-day suspension.
AWARD
Claimant's suspension shall be reduced to five days and he shall be paid
for all time out of service in excess of that amount.
Claim denied in all other respects.
The Carrier shall make this award effective forthwith.
~9~G16 ~'
V> > am . r en erqer/.
J
Chairman and Neutral Member
. Nay or. So lA. Hammons,,
Jr.
Carrier Member Employee Member'
Dated:
VAZ.d-01
. ~lpl~