AWARD NOS. 7, 9
CASE NOS. 7, 9
PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 4402
PARTIES ) BROTHERHOOD
OF MAINTENANCE OF WAY EMPLOYES
TO )
DISPUTE ) BURLINGTON
NORTHERN RAILROAD COMPANY
STATEMENT OF
CLAIM
(1) The dismissals of Assistant Foreman B. J. Huddle and Trackman T.
S. Jones for alleged violation of Rules 564, 574 and 575 were
without just and sufficient cause and wholly disproportionate to the
offenses with which charged.
(2) The Claimants shall be reinstated and afforded the remedy
prescribed by Agreement Rule 40G (System Files #10 Gr./10 DI -
T.S. Jones and #10 Gr.10/Dl - B. J. Huddle).
OPINION OF
BOARD
Claimants Huddle and Jones have seniority dates of May 26, 1979. As a result of
charges dated April 15, 1985, investigation held
on
April 23, 1985 and by letters dated
May 5, 1985, Claimants were dismissed for dishonesty and theft of Carrier property.
On April 6, 1985, Claimants went to a point on the Carrier's right of way near
Mullen, Nebraska and loaded approximately 32 new railroad ties onto a trailer owned by
Claimant Huddle's outside employer and took the ties to a location for delivery to that
employer. Claimants admit that they did not have authority from the Carrier to take the ties.
The cited rules prohibit dishonesty and further provide that theft is sufficient cause
for dismissal and that unauthorized possession of the Carrier's equipment and materials is
prohibited. Substantial evidence shows that Claimants clearly and admittedly violated those
rules. In this case, the fact that the ties may have appeared to Claimants to have been
abandoned does not justify the unauthorized removal of that material, especially since the
ties were new. Under the circumstances, we cannot say that dismissal was arbitrary or
capricious.
PLB 4402, Awards 7, 9
Page 2
AWARD
Claims denied.
Edwin H. Benn
Neutral Member
~j~
. J. Kallinen . Swanson
Carrier Member Organization Member
Denver, Colorado
December 7, 1988
~C,E Ep~
1989 1
~~B
o Office,