c c
PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 4816
* r
* In the Matter of the Arbitration between
*
* CSX Transportation Inc.
* (former Louisville & Nashville)
,artier
o the * and * case
No. 4
>ispute ' *
* Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes
* *
* *
STATEMENT OF CLAIM
1. C.E. Bennett 187021. 28. L.R. Tyson 186909**
2. D.D. Wiggins 186862. 29. S.R. Mims 188058.
3. T. Summers 188182. 30. M.E. Summers 188077.
4. B. Watkins 186968. 31. W. McClain 188103.
S. J.L. Watkins 186969 32. J.A.
Stinson 188152
.
6. R. Mims 187159. 33. L.C. Cravey 188179=
7. E.J. Watkins 187161. 34. J.C. Hill 188211.
8. L.A. Horton 187168. 35. L.L. Talbert 188339.
9. J.E. Watkins 187162. 36, K. Watkins 188419.
10. B.D. Barnett 187259** 37. B.W. Johnson 188453.
ll.- L. Stallvorth 187276. 38,
N.
Johnson 186229.
12. W.D. Dyers 187379. 39. L.R. Hawkins 188180
13. J.D. Fowler 187414. 40.J.A. Blackmon 188410.
14. J. Thomas 187453. 41. W.C. Smith 188338.
15.
W.
Watkins 187383. 42. A.J. Sinqui
16. H.M. Harrison 187477. field 188337.
17. B.A. Cuevas 187490. 43. J.B. Floyd 188332.
18. E. Hill 187594 44. C.W. Mosley 188230.
19. N.R. Fink 187721. 45. E.B. Jones 188439.
20. R. Fountain 187761. 46. K.L. Howard 188333
21. R.B. Elliott 187795· 47. W.J. Scott 187763·
22. R.L. Taylor 187801. 48.
M.
Saylor 186892**
23. J.P. Mclnvale 187818· 49. J.L. McMeans 188362
24. W.A. Bandy 187866 50. H.J. Simmons 174816**
25. J.L. Berry 187875 51. G.N. Nall 18670?
26. J. Grace 185752 52. W.J. Hawthorne188076
27. K.A. Du--bin 168145· 53. A.L- Williams 187799
54.D. Garett, Jr.174831**
~fB~W
2
"Be paid the difference between Southern Region
Rail Laying Gang rates of pay (No Wage Schedule
attached, account Carrier has not provided such,
as,per Rule 64), and that of wages paid them
(while assigned to Rail Gang 6M25) and (any
other employe who may be assigned thereafter).
"Also, each claimant should be paid mileage,
hotel expenses (if any), meal allowance of
6.50 each calendar day, and 25.00 (each -
claimant) for each week-end trip home.
These payments should start January 4, 1988
and continuous until the following viola
tions are discontinued, Award 298, Appendix
No. 27 and Past Practice.
Account, claimants were assigned to Rail
Gang 6M25...to commence work on January 4,
-1988. This Rail Gang was stationary at
Atmore, AL., without any benefits of
Award 298.
However, the Carrier had a set of Camp Cars
shipped from Corbin, KY. (approximately
500 miles or more) to Fiomaton, AL., which
is approximately 22 miles from Atmore, AL.,
and advised the employes that they could
stay in the Camp Cars. But, would not
roceive any benefits under Award 298."
OPINION OF THE BOARD
This case involves a 48-man Rail Gang headquartered at
Atmore, AL. On January 4, 1988, Carrier established the
Gang. It vas abolished on March 25, 1988. Petitioner con-
tends thzt the Gang should have been established as a Camp
Car Gang because Carrier moved camp cars about 500 miles and
placed them in Flomaton, Alabama, for people in the Atmore
Gang to use if they chose to do so.
3
Carrier stated, however, that the employes would not
get the benefits of Award 298 if they lived in the camp
cars.
This Board has reviewed three other cases involving
Carrier's establishing Fixed Headquarter Gangs where it made
camp cars available for employees to live in if they so
0
chose. The fact that Carrier makes these camp cars available for use by employes of Fixed Headquartered Gangs
apparently sends false signals to the employes. The
employes obviously think that because the camp cars are
made available for use, the Gang should be classified as a
camp car Gang and food and travel expenses paid. ':his
Board, as well as others, has taken the position that since
employes go on and off duty at the same headquarter's point
each day, Carrier is not obligated to pay food, lodging, or
travel expenses.
AWARD
The claim is denied.
R.Ef-Dennis, Neutral Member
B .C. Sweats, Carrier Member N.Jj. MarquGi ar, Employe Member
~ ~- a-C~
-90 _
Bate of Adoption