PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 4950
NEW JERSEY TRANSIT RAIL OPERATIONS, INC.
"Carrier"
VS.
BROTHERHOOD OF MAINTENANCE OF WAY EMPLOYES
"Organization"
OPINION OF THE BOAR!
Case No. 94
Award No. 87
By notice of hearing dated November 7, 1994, carrier
instructed claimant to appear at a hearing in connection with the
following:
On October 30, 1994, at approximately 1:45 a.m., on
Shrewsbury Ave. in Tinton Falls, -NJ, you operated
Company Vehicle B-1376, without authorization and
without a valid driver's license, in such a manner that
caused you to be stopped by NJ State Police and cited
for Motor Vehicle moving violations.
Therefore, in connection with this matter you are
charged with violation of: NJ Transit's Engineering
Department General Rules: B., D, para. 2 & 3, E. para.
1, L. para. 3 & 5 and General Safety Rules: 3335, 3341,
3343, 3348 and NJ Transit's Motor Vehicle Policy and NJ
Transit's Drug and Alcohol Free Workplace Policy
section IV, A. 3. "Prohibitions".
Following the hearing, Carrier found Claimant guilty as
charged, with the exception of deleting the alleged violation of
Rule 3348, and assessed him discipline of dismissal from all
service. The
Claimant's ten
willingness now
organization appealed, in part based
years of service with carrier as well as
to confront his problems and
upon
his
seek proper
treatment.
The Board has determined that the claim must be denied.
There is substantial evidence in the record to establish
Claimant's guilt of the charges alleged. Moreover, those charges
are extremely serious. Claimant appropriated a Carrier vehicle
without permission and was found to be intoxicated while
operating that vehicle. Claimant's illegal actions placed
himself and the public in jeopardy and exposed Carrier to
unnecessary liability. In these circumstances, it is not the
prerogative of the Board to reinstate Claimant based upon his
prior service nor based upon his commendable efforts to
rehabilitate himself subsequent to this matter.
AWARD
C im enied.
P C a es G. Ba bati
Ca Tr Member Organization Member
S. E. Buchheit
Neutral Member
2