PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 4950

NEW JERSEY TRANSIT RAIL OPERATIONS, INC.


VS.

BROTHERHOOD OF MAINTENANCE OF WAY EMPLOYES
"Organization"

OPINION OF THE BOAR!

Case No. 94

Award No. 87

By notice of hearing dated November 7, 1994, carrier instructed claimant to appear at a hearing in connection with the following:



Following the hearing, Carrier found Claimant guilty as charged, with the exception of deleting the alleged violation of Rule 3348, and assessed him discipline of dismissal from all


service. The

Claimant's ten
willingness now

organization appealed, in part based

years of service with carrier as well as

to confront his problems and

upon

his

seek proper
treatment.

There is substantial evidence in the record to establish Claimant's guilt of the charges alleged. Moreover, those charges are extremely serious. Claimant appropriated a Carrier vehicle without permission and was found to be intoxicated while operating that vehicle. Claimant's illegal actions placed himself and the public in jeopardy and exposed Carrier to unnecessary liability. In these circumstances, it is not the prerogative of the Board to reinstate Claimant based upon his prior service nor based upon his commendable efforts to rehabilitate himself subsequent to this matter.


AWARD



P C a es G. Ba bati
Ca Tr Member Organization Member


                  Neutral Member


2