PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 4950
NEW JERSEY TRANSIT RAIL OPERATIONS, INC.
"Carrier"
VS.
BROTHERHOOD OF MAINTENANCE OF WAY EMPLOYES
"Organization"
OPINION OF THE BOARD
Case No. 96
Award No. 89
By notice of hearing dated November 10, 1994, Carrier
instructed claimant to appear at a hearing in connection with the
following:
On Friday, November 4, 1994, at approximately 10:35
a.m. at Hoboken Terminal as you were being interviewed
by Mr. Daniel P. Smith, he noticed alcohol on your
breath. Your eyes were red, your speech slurred and
you had a stagger to your walk. Mr. Smith asked you if
you had been drinking. You responded that you drank
all night and that you had your last drink at 5:00 a.m.
on November 4, 1994. Mr. Smith transported you to
Maplewood where you were underwent a Drug and Alcohol
test. You tested positive for both cocaine and
alcohol.
Therefore, in connection with this matter you are
charged with violation of: NJ Transit Drug and Alcohol
Free Work Place Policy Section IV A 3 "Prohibitions"
(Page 6) and M W Engineering Department Safety Rule G.
Following the hearing, Carrier found
charged and assessed him discipline of
claimant guilty as
dismissal from all
service. The organization appealed, in part based upon the
contention that Carrier's EAP Program had failed Claimant by not
recognizing that he had a serious problem and also based upon the
stress and domestic problems Claimant was then experiencing.
The Board has determined that the claim must be denied.
The Board finds substantial evidence in the record to
support the allegations against Claimant. As Claimant tested
positive for both cocaine and alcohol, he was in violation of
Carrier's Drug and Alcohol Free Work Place Policy. Furthermore,
while Claimant did enter the EAP in 1991, the evidence does not
establish that officials at the EAP acted in a manner which now
justifies claimant's reinstatement. Finally, neither the
circumstances of Claimant's personal life, nor his commendable
determination to seek assistance after the events here at issue,
justify the Board ordering Claimant reinstated in light of the
seriousness of the offense involved.
WARD
Cl m denied.
P.I Charles G. Barbati
Cirrier member Organization Member
S. E. Buchheit
Neutral Member
2