PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 4950
NEW JERSEY TRANSIT RAIL OPERATIONS, INC.
"Carrier"
Vs.
BROTHERHOOD OF MAINTENANCE OF WAY EMPLOYES
"Organization"
Case No. 98
Award No. 91
OPINION OF THE BOARD
On March 31, 1994, the organization submitted the instant
claim on behalf of Claimant, K. Alfred, for all back wages from
Wednesday, March 9, 1994 until Thursday, March 24, 1994.
According to the claim, Claimant was cleared to work by his
attending physician without limitation as of March 9, 1994, and
when Claimant attempted to return to service on March 9 Carrier
barred him from doing so, with no
By letter dated April 26,
explanation.
1994, Carrier denied that claim.
Carrier subsequently denied the claim through all levels of
appeal. According to Carrier, on March 3 Claimant went to
Carrier's Medical Department for a return to work physical and
the physician in medical services sent Claimant to a specialist
for further testing, and when the results of the testing were
received on March 24, 1994, medical services declared Claimant
medically qualified to work the next day. Carrier asserts that
it took this action consistent with its rights under the Rules.
Carrier also maintains that the claim is procedurally defective
and that the Board is without authority to grant the remedy
sought.
The Board has determined that the claim must be denied.
Records indicate that Claimant was returning to work from an
extended medical leave of absence due to injuries diagnosed as
intervertebral disc herniation. Given the reason for Claimant's
absence, Carrier acted within its rights in having him examined
by a specialist rather than accepting without question the
assertion of Claimant or his doctor concerning Claimant's fitness
to return to work. Moreover, the record does not reveal that
Carrier acted arbitrarily or in any fashion unreasonably to
deprive Claimant of wages to which he was entitled.
AWE
C ai denied.
G ' .h .Arles G. Barbati
C 'ier Member Organization Member
S. E. Buchheit
Neutral Member