PARTIES
TO
DISPUTE

STATE.1IE1,1T OF C1.aTu


OPI`i1ION OF BOARD
Substantial evidence supports the Carrier's decision to discipline

PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 5392

BROTHERHOOD OF LOCOMOTIVE ENG LNEERS

CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.

Claimant for insubordination for failing to give sufficient breath for a breathalyzer test. However, under all of the circumstances, dismissal was excessive. Claimant shall be : eturned to service, subject to the usual return to duty eYaminaricns. Claimant shall not be e.^.titlec to compensation for :Line lest.


AWARD NO. 25 CASE N0.25

AWARD



the opinion.

r-~.r
Edwin H. Benr_
Neutral Member

/17/11 X0. 44 -
Carrier . ember

Organization Member

Jacksonville. Florida

Dated: