PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 56
PROCEDURAL AWARD NO. 1
PARTIES AKRON & BARBERTON BELT RAILROAD COMPANY
TO DISPUTE
BROTHERHOOD OF LOCOMOTIVE FIREMEN AND ENGINEMEN
NATURE OF DISPUTE:
The purpose of the Board as established pursuant to
Act of Congress Public Law 89 - 456, is to resolve a procedural dispute
between the parties.
The Board convened in Cleveland, Ohio, on July 20, 1967,
with all the members present.
FACTS:
The carrier dismissed Engineer D. C. Flaker on February
14, 1966. The organization rejected the dismissal, and allege that
there was a procedural failure on the part of the carrier. The
determination was referred to the disputes committee November 14,
1966 by letter of the organization.
On February 1, 1967, the organization, ex parte,
made submission of the Flaker claim to the First Division, National
Railroad Adjustment Board, which submission was received by the
First Division on February 5, 1967.On January 4, 1967, the carrier
p(-gsc9- A,-o 8~
requested of the Organization the establishment of a Public Law
Board. The organization denied this request on January 31, 1967.
On February 6, 1967 the Carrier made application to
the National Mediation Board for a partisan member of a Public Law
Board. This request was first denied as of February 28, 1967, but
later granted May 9, 1967. At the time the Carrier made request to
the organization for a public law board (January 4, 1967), the
Carrier did not list the disputes to be handled by the board, nor
was such a listing of disputes required by Act of Congress or the
rules of the National Mediation Board. Subsequently, the Carrier,
on January 20, 1967, advised the organization that the Flaker matter
was to be listed before the proposed Public Law Board.
FINDING AND AWARD:
The National Adjustment Board and Public Law Boards
have concurrent jurisdiction over both the parties and subject
matter of disputes submitted to their respective jurisdictions.
Once a dispute has been submitted to one tribunal, or the other, and
that tribunal has jurisdiction, such jurisdiction is exclusive. The
jurisdiction may be relinquished by the Adjustment Board, or Public
Law Board, or the jurisdiction may be removed, under section three,
second provision, of the Railway Labor Act, if the dispute has been
pending before the National Adjustment Board for 12 months or more.
2.
~L Q Sco
- Aeact~ I
A Public Law Board does not come into existence
until a majority of its members are appointed. The request
for a board does not create the board. Here, the board was
not in existence until May 9, 1967. The dispute, having been
submitted to the National Adjustment Board on February 6, 1967,
is within the exclusive jurisdiction of the First Division,
National Adjustment
Board, and cannot be considered by Public
Law Board No. 56 until subsequent to February 6, 1968, and only
if the matter is not then received by the National Railroad
Adjustment Board.
DATED: Cleveland, Ohio
December 20, 1967
organization Member
Carrier Member
Arthur W. Sempliner
Chairman and Neutral Member