Award No. 7
Docket No. 282 B
PUBLIC IAVT BOARD NO. 566 -
PENNSYLVANIA FEDERATION BROTHERHOOD OF MAINTENANCE. ~i itn
OF WAY EMPLOYES
vs
PENN CENTRAL TRANSPORTATION COMPANY
P
PA~
0~1C~ ~~
STATEMENT OF CLAIM: "M.W. Repair Shop.
~5'i
rt
ivy
System Docket 282-B, Logansport Repair Shop.
-Claim in behalf of H. R'fan for the time made
by H. E. Kerns beginning at 1:30 P.M. February
5, 1967,
and
ending when he returned to his headquarters."
OPINION OF BOARD: The essential facts are not in dispute: A heavy . .
snow created an emergency situation in the Chicago
Seniority District. Claimant and a junior employe held seniority in the
Logansport Repair Shop Soniority District. Carrier called the junior
employe, H. E. Kerns, to assist in the snow removal operation on Feb-
ruary 5 to February 8,
1967.
Claimant eras not called to go to Chicago;
instead he worked his regular assignment on February
6
and 7 and
marked
off sick on February 8,
1967.
The issue to be decided in this dispute is whether
Carrier has the right, under the Agreement, to assign a junior employe
to assist in emergency work in another seniority district in preference
to a senior employe.
Carrier takes the position that in an emergency
situation it is afforded greater latitude in assigning its employes,
particularly to work in a district where neither of the employes has
any seniority.
The Organization asserts that Carrier, once it
elects to call an employe to work in another seniority district, it
must call the employe in seniority order as they appear on their own
roster.
An analysis of the recird in this dispute and
precedent awards cited by both parties impels the conclusion that the
claim must be sustained. In Award No.
59'9,
the Board stated:
PL r3 510L
a,.
A
LJa, ,-
d
"Under a long line -if well-reasoned-decisions, to
which we adhere, we have held, with rules such as
are inv:·lved in the confronting record, that when
a Carrier elects ti call employees from an esta
blished seniority group ti perform work of another
group, there being n^ employees holding seniority
in the other group available, it is required to
. take notice of the seniority rights if the men in
the group called upin to perform the service. See,
e.g., Awards
2341, 4841, 4947, 5142
and 5604." '
Award No. 5939 also, as in this dispute, involved a
snow storm. See also Awards 5425 and
6306.
Claimant's recovery, however, is limited to the pro-
rata rate and m allowance is made for February S,
1967
when Claimant
marked off sick.
AWARD: The claim is sustained consistent with the
0pi^L:sn
herein. Order date is
30
days from the date of this
award. -
PUBLIC IAW BOARD N0.
566
/s/ Nicholas H. Zumas
Nicholas H. Zumas, Chairman
/s/ A. J. Cunningham /s/ S. J. Wilson
A.. J. Cunningham, Employe Member S. J. Wilson, Carrier Member
Signed and dated at Philadelphia, Penna. December 1S, 1970