PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 51150
Award No.
a ~~
Case No. 2$2
(Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employee
PARTIES TO QJ§PUTE:
(The Burlington Northam Santa Fe Railroad (Former
(ATSF Railway Company
STATEMENT OF CLAIM:
1. The Carrier violated the Agreement on Juno 7, 2006 when Claimant, C.
D. Morris, was dismissed for violating Section 7.4 of the BNSF Policy
on the Use of Alcohol and Drugs, for refusal to fast.
2. As a consequence of the violation referred to in part (1), the Carrier
shall Immediately reinstate the Claimant's seniority, vacation and all
other rights restored, remove any mention of this Incident
from his
personal record, and make him whole for arty wagon lost beginning
June 7, 2005 forward.
FINDINGS
Upon the whole record and all the evidence, the Board finds that the
parties
heroin are Carrier and Employee within the meaning of the Railway Labor Act, as
amended. Further, the Board is duly constitvbad by Agreement, has jurisdiction of tire
Parties and of the subject matter, and the Parties to this dispute were given due notice of
the hearing thereon.
Claimant was off work in excess of six months. The Cariara policy requires a
drug and alcohol test before returning to work.
Claimant
was scheduled for such a bas!
on March 29, 2005, He appeared promptly and on his first attempt to provide sufficient
urine that cook! be tested was unsuccessful.
Pursuant to Rules governing drug and alcohol testing, if the Indhrtdwl does not
furnish a sample quantity to be tested, he/she has three hours in which to do so.
CIaImarrYs
three-hour
window commenced at 0731, From 0731
until
1050, he
Page 2 Award No,
a va
cars No. 282
drank approximately 40 ounces of liquid. He also walked around the building twits, yet
he could not, or did not, furnish a sufficient quantity of urine at one thne that could be
tested.
Claimant was referred to a doctor to determine If Claimant had any physical
aiknerto or a shy bladder that hindered his ability to furnish a sufficient amount of urine
that could be tested. After the doctor's examination, the Carrier was advised Claimant
did not have a medical impairment that would prevent him from furnishing the required
amount of urine.
The Carrier then wrote Claimant on April 14, 2006, advising an Investigation was
established to determine his. "responsibility, H any, for refusing to participate hr required
testing alter being properly notified ...."
Following the Investigation, the Carrier on June T, 2005, wrote Claimant as
follows, advising him that:
"...as a resole
of formal Investigation that was held on May 10, 2005,
concerning your refusal to participate In required te:ft after being
properly notified; you are dismissed from employment for violation of
Section 7.4 of Burlington Northern Santa Fe Policy on the
Use of Alcohol
and Drugs, dated September i, 2003 "
During. the Investigation,
Claimant's
Repro argued that the Claimrrrt did
not refuse to participate ae charged by the Carrier in its charge letter. He lust simply
could not produce a sutiRcfent quantity of urns that could 6s 1.
The employee who cannot or will not furnish sufficient urine during a three-hour
period is considered refusing m participate in the drug testing; unless,
of counts, them
exists a medical reason why
is
cook! not be accomplished.
The on-property handling of the clean on Claimant's behalf argued Claimant did
Papa 3
Award No.
Cans No. 282
not refuse to participate and challenged the medical findings of no physical Impairment,
arguing the doctor who performed the physical and found nothing, did an Inadequate
physical.
This Board will not challenge the medical doctor's findings.
To this Board, 1M termination of Claimants employment and seniority was
sully
justified pursuant to terms and conditions of its Drug and Alcohol Policy.
The discipline will not be challenged.
AWARD
Claim denied.
ORDER
This Board, after consideration of the dispute Identified shove, hereby orders that
an award favorable to the Gialmanqs) not be made.
Robert L. Hicks, Chairman & Neutral Member
Rick
B.
WehrU, Labor Member
Dated:
a~,
Rdf~
'Iax~L
L4~1 ,
Samantha Ropers, Carver her