PUBLIC
LAW BOARD NO. 5850
Award No.
37q
Case No. 379
(Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes
PARTIES TO DISPUTE:
(The Burlington Northern Santa Fe Railroad (Former
(ATSF Railway Company)
STATEMENT OF CLAIM:
1. The Carrier violated the Agreement when Claimant Seth B. Sonny
was dismissed by letter dated April 1, 2009, for violation of MOWOR
Rules 1.5 Drugs and Alcohol concerning his second positive test
within a ten year period on December 9, 2008.
2. The dismissal of Claimant is harsh, extreme and in total abuse of
discretion. The Organization respectfully requests that Mr. Sonny be
reinstated to his former position with seniority, vacation and all other
rights unimpaired and compensated for all wage loss and/or
otherwise made whole beginning December 9, 2008, continuing
forward.
FINDINGS
Upon the whole record and all the evidence, the Board finds that the parties
herein are Carrier and Employee within the meaning of the Railway Labor Act, as
amended. Further, the Board is duly constituted by Agreement, has jurisdiction of the
Parties and of the subject matter, and the Parties to this dispute were given due notice of
the hearing thereon.
There was a minor accident in which on-track machinery collided with a small
trailer. The responsible crewmembers were tested for banned substances in accordance
with the rules. Subsequent to Claimant's positive result, his second in a 10 year period,
an Investigation was scheduled.
"You are hereby notified to attend formal Investigation ...on Thursday,
December 18, 2008, to develop the facts and circumstances concerning
your positive Reasonable Cause test, while working as Machine Operator,
Page 2 PLB NO. 5850
Award No. 37 q
Case No. 37'9
on December 9, 2008, on the Brookfield Sub Division, and your alleged
violation of BNSF Policy on the use of Alcohol and Drugs, dated September
1, 2003."
The Investigation was held on March 4, 2009 after a number of agreed to
postponement requests. Claimant was properly notified but he elected, at his peril, not
to attend the Investigation. The Carrier proceeded with the Investigation without
Claimant. Under these circumstances, Carrier's proof of its charges went unchallenged.
The Carrier's decision to dismiss is supported by this Board.
AWARD
Claim denied.
GIRDER
This Board, after consideration of the dispute identified above, hereby orders that
an award favorable to the Claimant(s) not be made.
Robert L. Hicks, C airman & Neutral Member
lLn
.` ~'riT'L~ ~ Wrw.s~... '/
David D. Tanner, For the Employees Samantha Rogers, For the er
Dated:
;2f/a%,''/f~