AWE NO. 25 CASE NC). 25

PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 5943

PART
TO
DISPUTE

STATE NT OF CLAIM

BROTHERHOOD of LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERS

UNION PAcrFic RAmRoAD Cone

Claim on behalf of Engineer J. M. Allen to have record cleared of a Level 2 discipline assessed for responsibility in connection with a derailment


After investigation held on April 26, 1995, the Carrier issued notice to Claimant on May 12, 1995 that he was assessed a Level 2 discipline in connection with a derailment of three cars on April 18, 1995.


Article 44, paragraph 3 requires, in pertinent part, that "A decision shall be rendered within ten (10) days following completion of the investigation." The May 12, 1995 discipline in this case from the April 26, 1995 investigation did not meet that 10 day requirement. In light of the configuration of the yard established by the record, had this Board been able to reach the merits of this claim we would have denied the same. However, Article 44, paragraph 3 prevents us from reaching


the merits. The discipline was untimely. The claim shall be sustained.

The discipline is rescinded and Claimant shall be made whole in all

Claim sustained.

Edwin H. Benn
Neutral Member




Organization Member
W. R. Slone II

Fort Worth, Texas

Dated: )11111ff