AWARD NO. 28
CASE NO. 28
PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 5943
PARTIES
TO
DISPUTE ) UNION PACIFIC RATI ROAD COMPANY
BROTHERHOOD OF LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERS
STATEMENT OF Cl
Removal of dismissals from
the record of Engineer G. L.
Holloway for his alleged vio
lation of Rules 1.5 (drug and
alcohol violation) and Rule
9.5 (failure to stop before
passing stop signal) of the
General Code of Operating
Rules of the Union Pacific
Railroad and pay for time lost
with seniority and vacation
rights unimpaired.
OPINION OF BOARD-
Claimant, an Engineer with
28
years of service, was dismissed as a
result of his failing to stop before
passing a red signal and for testing
positive for alcohol.
Ordinarily, given the facts in this
case and Claimant's prior record,
this Board would not hesitate to
uphold Claimant's dismissal.
However, we note that Claimant's
conductor on the date in question.
J. D. Pierce, was dismissed for similar reasons, but was "returned to
service, but only with entry into the
companion program." PLB 3889,
Award No. 110 a & b.
We also note
that Claimant is a
28
year employee.
Under the circumstances of this
case, Claimant shall be given the
same opportunity as Pierce on a last
chance basis, as follows:
First, within 14 days of the date
of this award, Claimant shall enter
the EAP.
Second, Claimant shall comply
with all aspects of the program designed for him by the appropriate
EAP counselor. As part of the program designed by the counselor,
Claimant must regularly attend AA,
NA, or equivalent type meetings, the
frequency and type to be determined
by the
EAP
counselor. Claimant
shall also execute necessary releases
so that the EAP counselor can regularly inform the Carrier of
Claimant's progress and so that any
medical records deemed necessary by
the Carrier can be provided.
Third, the duration of Claimant's
participation in the EAP shall be de-
PL8 5943. Award 28
G. L. Holloway
Page 2
termined by the EAP counselor, but Eighth, Claimant's reinstatement
shall be no less than two years. shall be without compensation for
Fourth, in addition to any time lost, but without loss of
drug/alcohol testing required by the seniority.
Carrier in the ordinary course or Ninth, Claimant shall be given a
through the EAP, Claimant shall be copy of this award by the Carrier
subject to random drug/alcohol and Claimant shall sign a
copy ac
testing as determined by the Carrier. knowledging that he understands
This Board strongly recommends the contents of this award.
that Claimant be randomly tested $
on a very frequent basis. Claim sustained in accord with
Fifth, Claimant shall be permit- the opinion. i
ted to return to active duty only
upon clearance by the EAP coun
selor and by the Carrier and further Edwin H. Benn
contingent upon Claimant's passing Neutral Member
a return to duty physical.
Sixth, in the event Claimant fails
~--to
comply
with any aspect of the Carrier Membe
A. C. Hallberg
program designed by the EAP coun
selor, or if it is determined by the
EAP counselor that Claimant is not drganizaho4Mk Pr ,a
succeeding in the program, or if M. L. Royal, Jr.
Claimant fails to execute necessary
v
releases called for in this award, or Fort Worth, Texas
if Claimant fails to comply with
any
aspect of this award, Claimant shall Dated:
~ Z ~ ~~
be
immediately
discharged.
Seventh, if after the date of this
award, and for the duration of his i
employment with the Carrier.
Claimant should
ewer
test positive
on a random or other drug/alcohol
test. Claimant shall be
immediately
i