Parties to Dispute: Union Pacific Railroad Company
and
Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers
Statement of .aim
Removal of Level 4 discipline and pay for all time lost associated with the discipline issued
to Engineer 7.G. McGee in reference to a charge of speeding on other than main track.
Find~intrc_
Serious inconsistencies in the event recorder remain unexplained
1·iz.
a jump of 12 mph in one
second. Claimant cannot be held responsible for a speed reading that does not reflect his actual speed.
The Carrier did not meet the burden of establishing a rule violation.
Award
Claim sustained.
Francis X. Qui
Chair and Neutral Member
\.
Don Hahs Terry Stone
Organization Member Carrier Member
Date v · /~, o
2"dega
Ft. rth, Texas