image


image


image



image image


image


image



image


image


image


image


image on


image l 1 1 1 1 image


a image m image


image

4

Award No. 292

PLB No. 7163


image image


image


image


image


image


image


image



image



image



image



image



image



image


image image image image image



image



Page 2 of 4

image

Award No. 292

PLB No. 7163

image

burden of proof. The work claimed did not take place. The claim should be denied in its entirety.

image

image

image

image

The Board has carefully reviewed the record before us and discovered no fatal procedural errors. The Organization has built the majority of their case on circumstantial evidence. The Board notes that the record does not support the claim of fencing work. In this instance, based on the record before us, the Organization has failed to substantiate their burden of proof. The claim will be denied.


image

AWARD:


Case denied.


Page 3 of 4

image

PLB No. 7163

Award No. 292


image

Don A. Hampton

Neutral Chairman and Referee


image


Katrina Donovan

Carrier Member

Andrew M. Mulford

image

Employee Member


DATED:

July 13, 2018

image


Page 4 of 4