' SPECIAL BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT 1110
Award No. 160
Case No. 160
PARTIES TO DISPUTE:
Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employees
and
CSX Transportation, Inc.
STATEMENT OF CLAIM:
Claim of the System COMMittee of the Brotherhood that:
1. The Carrier violated the Agreement when it failed to
bulletin a foreman/flagman position in connection with
providing flag protection for contractor installing fiber
optic cable between Mile Posts A763.7 and A840.9 on the
Sanford Subdivision and when it failed and refused to assign
Foreman/Flagman R. P. Jennings to perform foreman/flagman
duties on the Sanford Subdivision beginning January 10, 2000
and continuing through March 18, 2000 and instead assigned
junior Employes C. K. Hundley, J. Jones and J. V. Daughtery
[System Files B16609000/12(00-0386) and B16608400/12(00
0348) CSX].
2. As a consequence of the violation referred to in Part
(1) above, Claimant R. P. Jennings shall now be compensated
for three hundred seven (307) hours' pay at the respective
foreman/flagman's time and one-half rate of pay and be paid
for the weekly per diem and travel allowance for the period
beginning January 10, 2000 through March 18, 2000.
FINDINGS:
This Board, upon the whole record and all of the evidence, finds
and holds as follows:
1. That the Carrier and the Employee involved in this
dispute are, respectively, Carrier and Employee within the
meaning of the Railway Labor Act, as amended,; and
2. That the Board has jurisdiction over this dispute.
OPINION OF THE BOARD:
Rule 3 (Selection of Positions) provides, in pertinent part:
1
S(3h II10
Ib0
8a,.~i.:ion 3. Advertisement and away::.
(a) All positions and vacancies will be advertised
within thirty (30) days previous to or within twenty
(20) days following the dates they occur. The
advertisement shall show position title, rate of pay,
headquarters, tour of duty, rest days and designated
meal period.
Section 4. Filling temporary vacancies
(a) A position or vacancy-may be filled temporarily
pending assignment. When new positions or vacancies
occur, the senior qualified available employees will be
given preference, whether working in a lower rated
position or in the same grade or class pending
advertisement and award. When furloughed employees are
to be used to fill positions under this Section, the
senior qualified furloughed employees in the seniority
district shall be offered the opportunity to return to
service. Such employees who return and are not awarded
a position or assigned to another vacancy shall return
to furlough status.
A careful review of the record indicates that the Carrier failed
to bulletin the referenced Foreman/Flagman position until
February 14, 2000 even though the performance of the disputed
work began on January 10, 2000. By failing to act in a timely
manner, the Carrier thereby violated Rule 3 of the Agreement.
The record further proves that the Claimant held seniority within
the Track Department and was working as a Track Inspector in the
relevant territory and during the relevant time. The record
contains sufficient evidence to prove that the Claimant had
sought to perform the disputed work in a timely manner as
reflected by an unrefuted letter, dated August 24, 2000,
furnished by the Claimant. (Attachment 3 to Employes' Exhibit
C.) Although the evidence proves that the Claimant had greater
seniority than the employees who performed the disputed work, no
credible evidence exists in the record that the Claimant ever bid
for the bulletined position. As a result of the claimant's
greater seniority, the carrier had a contractual obligation
pursuant to Rule 3 to assign the disputed work to the senior
Claimant rather than the junior employees who actually performed
the disputed work.
Under these precise circumstances, the Claimant shall be
compensated for the overtime that occurred in the performance of
the disputed work between January 10, 2000 and February 14, 2000.
No basis exists in the present record for the Claimant to receive
2
Sb~wo
%.co:apensation after February 14, 2006 cti to receive the requested
weekly per diem and/or travel allowance.
AWARD:
The Claim is sustained in accordance with the Opinion of the
Board. The Carrier shall make the Award effective on or before
60 days following the date of this Award.
L.l
Robert L. Doq~rlas
Chairman and Neutral Member
7
D. . Bartho o .T. li zak
Emp ee Member Carrier ember
Dated:
3