C SPZCIAL BOARD OF ADJUSTi-1GNT N0. 122
 0
 P THE PITTSBURGH AND LAKE ERIE RAILROAD COMPANY Award No. 20^
 Y THE LAKE ERIE AND EASTERN RAILROAD 0014PADIY Case No. 7
 vs
 BROTHERHOOD OF RAMIAY AIM STEAMSHIP CLERKS,
 FREIGHT HANDLERS, EXPRESS AND STATIOL'I EI'IPLOYES

 ' OF CLAIIq:

 210^ claims as set forth below for eight hours at time and one-half account of clerical vacancies at East Youngstown General Yard being filled b non-employees in violation of Rule 1, Scope, of the Clerks? Agreement. (CL-21g~
 Claimant Job Number Date Job .lumber Date
 H, Montgomery Job 135 10- 3-53 Job 135 10- 4-53


                        :7 173 11- 1-53 " 244 11- 8-53

                        :v 264 11-14.-53 ·° 225 11-15-53

                    Ex 9AK Janitor 11-21-53 ·~ 244 11-22-53

                    Job 363 11-29-53 ° 334 12- 5-53

                    264 12-12-53 ' 155 12-13-53

                    124 12-19-53 ·' 211 12-20-53

                    ~i ill 12-26-53 ·' 254 12-27-53


D. E. Curran Job 234 10- 3-53 Job 244 10- 4-53
                        155 10-11-53 i' 313 10-17-53

                        ·P 211 10-24-53 " 313 10-25-53

                        144 11- 1-53 ·° 243 11- 8-53

                        29 11-14-53 i° 29 11-15-53

                        233 11-21-53 0 29 11-22-53

                        °° 155 12- 5-53 °' 173 12- 6-53

                        333 12-12-53 " 173 12-13-53

                        264 12-19-53 ·' 244 12-20-53

                        325 12-26-53' 155 12-27-53

                        29 11-28-53


J. U. Flaherty. Jr. Job 244 10-11-53 Job 144 10-10-53
 4 244 12- 6-53 °° 364 12-13-53
 F. Yazbek Job 225 11-14-53 Ex 9AM Janitor 11-21-53
 363 11-28-53 Job 144 11-29-53
 " 354 12-12-53 4 234 12-27-53
 E. L. Giblin Job 27 10- 9-53 Job 254 10-10-53
 '0 313 10-23-53 '° 17.1 12-13-53
 153 12-19-53° 134 12-25-53
                        ·e 134 1- 1-54

                                            Award No. 23

                                            Case No. 7


Claimant Job Number Date Job Number Date
 D, E. fewitt Job 254 10-17-53
 Job 27 10-20-53
 r~ 333 11-17-53 " 353 11-25-53
 125 12- 2-53 p 273 12- 9-53
 .r 32 12-17-53 F7 211 12-19-53
 E. TI. Bernat Job 355 12-2$-53 Job 225 12-29-53
 Grey Job 163 10-10-53 Job 235 10-11-53
 J_Wtl. ,t 33 10 17-53 ' 144 10-25=53

                      'e 334 11-14-53 '~243 11-15-53

                      313 11-28-53 'p 313 12- 6-53

                      213 12- 5-53 '4 173 12-12-53


                      23 12-26-53

                      73 P 163 12-27-53

                      .7 243 1- 3-54


E. J. Powers Job 155 11- 1-53 Ex 3AY4 Janitor 11-1.4-53
 173 11-22-53 Job 211 11-26-53
 244 11-29-53~ 311 12- 5-53
 325 12-11-53 'P 155 12-20-53
 243 12-26-53 P 14.4 12-27-53
 J. A. Marinelli Job 243 10-17-53 Job 27 10-23-53
 264 10-24-53 'p 233 10-30-53
 .e 244 10-31-53 Ex SAM Janitor 11-1.4-53
 ·~ 29 11-27-53 Job 354 12-11-53
 ~= 27 12-18-53 112 336 12-19-53
 H. C. Gamble Job 343 10.-7.1-53 Job 244 10-13-53
 .1 155 10-25-53 9 124 11- 1-53
 fP 134 11.- 8-53 " 244 11-15-53
 313 11-29-53
 R. A. Barber Job 32 12-24-53
 D. 2. Brown Job 27 10-29-53
 C. L. 7nakeen job 364 12-23-53

 LT. J. §.c id Job 313 10- 3-53 Job 113 10- 3-53
 113 10-10-53 9 144 10-11-53
 113 10-17-53 ~P 113 10-18-53
 113 10-25-53 a 113 10-24-53
 .V 113 10-31-53

 E. D. Yatsko Job 253 11-29-53 Job 373 12- 6-53
 113 12-26-53

                          - 2 -

                                              Award No. 28

                                              Case No. 7


Claimant Job Agmber Date Job Namber Date
 B. H. Butcher Job 363 10-17-53 Job 173 10-18-53
                        it 334 10-23-53 °' 353 10-24-53

                        353 10-31-53 '° 32 11- 7-53

                        e, 225 11-13-53 °' 124 11-14-53

                        " 355 12-11-53 " 111 12-12-53

                        y1 313 12-18-53 " 313 12-19-53

                        it 2,43 12-25-53


A. TL Calcagni Job 234 12-24-53 Job 263 1z-31-53
 1. F. Frush Job 324 12-30-53 Job 32 7-2-31-53
 G. M. Doman Job 355 111- 9-53 Job 2 843 12-2_53
 135-2
 J. 14. Conrov Job 244 12-24-53 Job 325 12-25-53
 " 373 12-31-53
 x. W. Calderwood Job 225 11- 7-53 Job 236 11-14-53
 155 11-15-53 " 355 12-12-53
 225 12-19-53 " 225 12-20-53
 r, 2,4 12-26-53 " 264 12-27-53
 '' 263 1- 3-54
 E. A. Sebest Job 33 11-12-53 Job 313 11-27-53
                        e, 27 10-30-53 " 27 12-10-53

_ 313 12^11.-53 " 155 12-24-53
 w. B. Hetrick Job 225 10- 7-53 Job 373 10-1h-53
                        " 32 10-15-53 " 264 10-17-53

                        334 11-18-53 " 313 10-21-53

                        it 32 10-22-53 " 32 10-29-53

                        243 10-25-53 " 333 11- 4-53

                        233 12- 2-53 " 32 12- 3-53

                        r, 235 12-21-53 " 225 12-22-53

                        '' 111 12-23-53 '° 363 12-24-53

                        " 364 1.2-30-53 " 254 12-31-53


PT. W. Frush Job 225 11-25-53 Job 355 12- 8-53
 Y' 133 12-23-53 " 333 12-23-53
 223 12-24-53 " 364 12-29-53
 Y' 263 12-30-53
 H. J. Mevers Job 264 10-11-53 Job 313 10-18-5:
                        " 173 10-25-53 " 243 7.1- 1-53

                        yr 27 11-15-53 " 7.55 11-29-53

                        _ 263 12- 6-53 " 355 12- 7-53

                        333 12-13-53 " 323 12-14-53

                        " 155 12-29-53 " 225 1- 3-54

                          -3-

                                            Award No. 28

                                            Case No. 7


Claimant Job Number Date Job Number Date
 R. L. Stiteler Job 336 12-23-53 Job 264 12 24-53
 323 12-30-53
 P. E,, ,McGuire Job 243 10-11-53 Job 363 10-18-53
 354 10-25-53 ~P 244 11- 1-53
 243 11- 2-53 ~' 155 11- 8-53
 264 11-15-53 '° 355 11-16-53
 324 12- 7-53 " 27 U-17-53
 D. D. Baker Job 155 12- 6-53 Job 164 12-13-53
 ie 313 12-20-53 '° 28 12-21-53

 FINDINGS: The Board, upon the whole record and all the evidence, finds that:

The Carrier or Carriers and the employee or employees involved in this dispute are respectively Carrier and Employee within the meaning of the Railway

Labor Act, as approved June 21, 1934.

 The Board has jurisdiction over the dispute involved herein. The parties to said dispute were given due notice of hearing thereon.

 This cause of action is progressed by regularly assigned clerical employees and not by furloughed workers. Clearly, the seniority preferences preserved to furloughed employees by Rule 14 does not extend to persons holding regular jobs.

 Once the furloughed list is exhausted, there is nothing in the Labor Agreement either standing to bar Carrier from hiring such additional new employees as may be necessary to meet its business demands, or making it mandatory that the regular force be utilized on rest days to fill temporary job openings rather than resort to extra employees as the source-of additional manpower. In the first place, if extra employees are available, it is the Carrier who has the discretion as to whether or not it will extend overtime work opportunities to regularly assigned employees. Then, too, Rules 6, 2512 (h) and 28 (d) recognize that extra, as distinguished from furloughed employees, may be on the payroll. Also, the record in this case does not shut out the possibility that the extra employees here involved could conceivably establish seniority and gain other rights under the Clerks' Agreement.

 Claims denied.

              SPECIAL BOARD OF ADJUSTIMT N0. 122


              Isl Harold FI. Gilden

              Harold M. Gilden, Neutral and Only Member Thereof


Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania April 24, 1958
                          _4_