a















          FINDINGS: At Richland, Ohio a conductor of a work train holding an

          order to work on the territory west of Hamden copied a

          train order from the operator at West Junction. There has never been

          a telegraph office at Richland. Only this one isolated instance of

          copying train orders at that point is shown.


          For the reasons stated in the Findings in Dockets 1 and 19 we find no basis for a sustaining award here.


                              AWARD


          Claims (1), (2) Denied.


                        /s/ Francis J. Robertson

                          Francis J. Robertson,

                          Chairman


          ,s/ B. N. Kinkead Isl T. S. Woods

          B. N. Kinkead, T. S. Woods

          Employee Member (Dissenting) Carrier Member


          Dated at Baltimore, Maryland this 24th day of April, 1957.