C AWARD N0. 44
 0 CASE N0. 47
 P SS4'd FILE R-51-1086-1
 Y BRC FILE NR-27-1


PARTIES) The Brotherhood of Railway and Steamship Clerks
 TO )
 DISPUTE) St. Louis Southwestern Railway Company
STATEMENT OF CLAIM: Claim of the System Committee of the Brotherhood:
(1) That Carrier violated, and continues to violate, the Clerks? current Agreement at Pine Bluff, Arkansas, in instructing and requiring the Icing Foreman to perform clerical work in compiling and rendering icing and refrigeration reports - Ori;inal Record of Shipments Retop Iced (Pam 3232)0 and Original Record of Perishable Freight Service (Form 3234), on cars of perishables which required, or require, re-icing retop ice or heater service at Pine Bluff Yard.
(2) That Yard Clerk R. R. Holden be compensated for one hundred sixty five hours and five minutes (1651 5i') at time and one-half Yard Clerk rate, viz:
DATE TIME CLAIMED DATE TIME CLAIMED
 November $, 1955 5? 159° December l; 1955 2? 15'1
 f1 9i ;t 7? Oil ii 2l ii 4? Oil
 .i 10; ii 6? 02l si 3~ ii 11 4511
 it 11i, it 2? Oil .. 4i it 2? 20"
 it 131 0 2? 30" it 5j; it 4? 35ii
 ii 14; ii 2c oil :i 6;i it 211 Of?
 ci 15j ii 9? 4011 it 7s it 2? oil
 ei 16s :3 47 1494 .1 g9 it 31 1511
 :i 179 % 2? Oil .i 9i it 2? Oil
 :2 19., i1 4? 021 1t 131 ii 4? 0i'
 ii 201 re 3? loll a 141 iv 2? Oil
 .r 21s .i 6? 30i, 15s 92 42 Oil
 si 222 ;i 0 40r1 e1 16, U 22 511
 a 23s .1 61 357i ii 19' it 2? 1011
 a 24-, it 49 2012 it 20 ii 6? 50:?
 .r 26p 1i 21 0il ,e 213 ii 99 20"
 ii 281 ii 6e 1011 1? 23~ it 2v 35'Q
 a 2% .i 29 201? .e 25' 71 21 30"
 a 30, 71 21 Oil- ii 26~ ii 22 20.1
 849 25ii :i 290 ci 0' 50,1
 a 301 ii 2? 35ei



DATE TIPIE CLAIMED 689 30«
 January 2, 1956 2t 30'9 849 259'
 ,e 3j to 49 Ort
 It 4i ;~ 29 Div
 V 40" 12~ 10~r
                            TOtale.e 165 51'


and be compensated accordingly for dates subsequent to January 6, 1956, the Icing Foreman is instructed and required to perform this clerical work. All subsequent violations to be determined by a joint check of Carrier's payroll and other records.

 SINDINGS: Prior to claim date here the Icing Foreman made memorandums on switch
 lists as to the data in connection with the icing of refrigerated cars
 at Pine Bluff. When more than six cars at a time were involved a yard clerk was
 used to perform this work.

 Subsequent thereto a printed form was used to make the memorandums about the re-icing, instead of the switch lists as had been used previously. We see no distinction between the two methods of doing the work. It was merely a memorandum of the actual work performed and could properly be performed by the foreman. It was the practice to use a clerk when there were more than six cars at a time involved.

 If, under the circumstances in the instant claim, there were instances where more than six cars at a time were involved and no clerk used to perform it, claimant should be paid a call for tlv amount of time necessary to dispose of the cars in question.

 These Findings include the dates specified in the claim, but do not contemplate subsequent dates as such a claim would be too indefinite.

 AWARD: Claim disposed of in keeping with the above Findings.

                  /s/ Frank P. Douglass

                  Frank P. Douglass, Chairman


/s/ W. E. Straubin7er Is/ L~t C. Albert
 II. E. Straubinger, Employee Member L. C. Albert, Carrier Member

 Tyler, Texas I-lay 2, 1957.

                          _2-