SPIXIAL BOARD OF ADJUSTViENT NO. 171
 
BRGTM';HCGD OF 
?.AILWAY 
AND 
STEAMSHIP 
CLERKS,
FREIGHT HANDLERS, EXTRESS 
AND STATION 
EMPLOYEES
GREAT 
NORTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY
STATEMENT 
OF CLAIM:
Claim of the System Committee of the Brotherhood of Xailway and Steamship
Clerks, Freight Handlers, Express and Station Employes that the Carrier violated the current agreement.
1. When they abolished two positions of Assistant Warehouse
Foreman and concurrently therewith established two positions of Warehouse
Foreman at Great Falls, Montana.
2. 
That the Carrier be required to compensate Thomas Chavez
for all wage loss sustained commencing with the date of November 
26, 1956 
and
for all dates subsequent thereto because of the abolishment of his position.
3. That the Carrier be required to compensate Charles Campbell
for all wage loss sustained commencing with the date of November 
26, 1956 
and
for all dates subsequent thereto because of the abolishment of his position.
4. 
That the Carrier be required to compensate all other employes
adversely affected for all wage loss sustained by reason of this violation.
FINDINGS: This Special Board of Adjustment upon the whole record and all the
evidence, finds that:
The claimants contend that the Carrier has violated Rule 3(b) of
the Effective Agreement. This rule states that certain positions are excepted
from the application of promotion, assignment and displacement rules. Under
Rule 3(b), we find that Foremen come under this rule at Great Falls Freight
Yard.
The claimants state that when the agreement was originally written
it was the intent of the parties that the plural would be designated tChief
Clerks' and 'Forement) simply because there was more than one station involved,
It was never Intended that there would be more than one foreman at each of
these stations.
AWARD N0. 34
 
CASE N0. 34
The Board finds that the contention of the claimants is not well
founded, as the word 'Foremen' is used in the rule and that the Board is bound
by the rule. Therefore, the Carrier did not violate Rule 3(b) when it
established two (2) new Foremen positions at Great Falls on November 23, 1956.
A W A R D
Claim denied.
/s/ Thomas C. Begley
 
Thomas C, Begley, Chairman
/s/ , A,A, ,Pearson
son, Carrier Member
/s/ C. C. Denewith
 
C. C. Denewith, Employee Member
Signed at St. Paul, Minnesota this 10th day of December, 
1958.
_2 _