_ SPECIAL BOARD OF ADJUSTIYIENT N0.
173
PARTIES TO DISPUTE: Brotherhood of Railway and Steamship Clerks
Freight Handlers, Express and Station Employes
Union Pacific Railroad Company
STATEMENT OF CLAIM: "Claim of the System Committee of the Brotherhood of Railway
and Steamship Clerks, Freight Handlers, Express and Station
Employes that:
1. Carrier violated Rules
24
and
25
when they established clerical position, Hays,
Kansas, at rate (current) of
$336.44
per month and since the establishment permitted higher rated work to flow to this position without an appropriate adjustment
in the rate of pay.
2.
The Carrier shall now be required to reclassify this position to that of Bill
and Rate Clerk and adjust the rate of pay to
$366.24
per month.
3.
Carrier now be required to compensate Claimant W, A. Harries the difference
between rate of
$336.44
per month and
$366.24
per month, effective January 1,
1951,
continuing until such time as the violation is corrected.'
FINDINGS: The Board, upon the whole record and all the evidence, finds that:
The Carrier or Carriers and the Employee or Employees involved in this
dispute are respectively Carrier and Employee within the meaning of the Railway
Labor Act, as approved June
21, 1934.
The Board has jurisdiction over the dispute involved herein. The parties
to said dispute were given due notice of hearing thereon,
When, on April
30, 1951,
Carrier refused to participate in a joint check
and rejected the suggestion that claimant was improperly classified, (a contention
first advanced by the organization on December
12, 1950),
the matter was not further
pursued until August
29, 1955.
Thereafter, it was diligently progressed. Clearly,
Carrier should not be penalized for the interval during which this cause of action
was permitted to lie dormant,
An examination of the results obtained from the joint check of the
clerks position at Hays, Kansas, made by the parties on October
23, 1956,
reveals
that a substantial portion of claimants time is devoted to the performance of
higher rated work. Insofar as Rule
26
envisions the prospect of an upward rate
adjustment in instances where repeated and gradual increases in job duties and
responsibilities ultimately offer a legitimate basis of comparison with higher rated
existing positions in the same division of the Operating Department and the same
seniority district of other departments, it is apparent that claimant herein is
entitled to some measure of relief.
Giving consideration to the substantial amount of time devoted by the
claimant to the performance of job elements applicable either to the classifications
of Rate and Bill Clerk at Salina, Kansas, or Yard Clerk at Salina, Kansas, a
$7,99
per month increase in claimant's job rate is justified,
Award No. 26
Case No. .19
AWARD: 1, That Carrier violated Rule 26 of the Clerks' Agreement when it failed to
appropriately adjust the rate of pay for the Clerks position at Hays, Kansas.
2. That Carrier forthwith shall put into effect a 0.99 monthly increase
in the rate of pay now prevailing for the Clerkla position at Hays, Kansas, and
remunerate claimant with said increment retroactive to September 1, 1955.
SPECIAL BOARD OF ADJUSZh!ENT N0. 173
/s/ Harold M. Gilden
Chairman
/s/ A. J. VanDercreek
Carrier Member
(I
dissent
/s/ C. F, Bignall
Organization Member
Omaha, Nebraska
February 24, 1959