C Docket No. OL-7789
0 Award No. 13
P
Y SPECIAL BOARD OF ADJUVENT N0. 177 (PRR)
STATEMENT OF CLAIM: Claim of the System Comittee of the Brotherhood that:
(a) The Carrier violated the Rules Agreement, effective May 1, 1942,
except as amended, particularly Rules 3-B=1 and 3-B=2 when fifty cars of freight
consigned to President Station, Baltimore, Maryland, were diverted to Trenton,
New Jersey, and unloaded at that point.
(b) L. A. Muscella and one hundred six other named employes at President
Station be allowed settlement in an equal distribution of the claim on the basis
of twelve hours pay for each carload so diverted.
Docket E-915)
FINDINGS: It appears from the record that the President Street (or Station)
Freight House at Baltimore is maintained as transfer point for LCL
freight, which is fluctuating and unpredictable in volume, and there is no complaint that Carrier's facilities and employed forces were not adequate for the
normal handling of the work. We think the record further shows that at the times
of the diversion of cars to Trenton, the President Street Freight House and the
available gangs of employes there were being used substantially to full capacity
without being able to keep their work current; that a serious congestion of freight
and delay in handling resulted; that in handling LCL freight speed is particularly
important, and that the use of more gangs or of more overtime was not practicable
for speeding the work.
The sole shown purpose of the diversions of cars to Trenton was to
relieve the congestion at President Street; the number of cars diverted was no
more than necessary to relieve the congestion and the diversions are not shown to
have interfered with subsequent full time employment at President Street.
The Employes take the position that "Rule 3-E-1 provides that work cannot be transferred from one seniority district to another without proper action
under the rules agreements? and that the employes at President Station had an absolute right to handle all cars consigned to that station.
Carrier does not deny that the clerical forces have the contract right
to perform this work but it does deny that the contract gives the right exclusively to employes holding seniority at the President Street Freight House.
We shall not attempt to determine that issue. We think the claim is
properly determinable on another ground. It is an elementary rule of law that in
any contract where there is no provision as to time for performance a reasonable
time is implied. What constitutes reasonable time depends on the situation and
circumstances involved. So under the contract before us, balancing any right of
the employes to perform work is the obligation to perform that work with reasonable
dispatch, and where because of conditions beyond Carrierls control the employes
are unable to accomplish timely performance, Carrier may, to the extent necessary
to permit adequate performance, remove the accumulated backlog of work to another
seniority district. Such was the situation here.
Award No. 13
Claim denied.
Signed this 17th day of July, 1957.
(s/ R. H. Skinner. Jr,
R. H. Skinner, Jr., Carrier Member S. V. . Loehr, Employe Member
/s/ Mortimer Stone
Mortimer Stone - Chairman