SPECIAL BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT NO. 279
Award No. 327
Case No. 327
File No. 870-507
Parties Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employees
to and
Dispute Union Pacific Railroad Company
(Former Missouri Pacific Railroad Company)
Statement
of Claim: (1) Carrier violated the Agreement, especially Rule 12,
when Trackman A. P. Phillips was dismissed from the
service on March 16, 1987.
(2) Claimant Phillips should now, therefore, be allowed
compensation for time lost from February 27, 1987 until
reinstated with all past privileges, vacation and seniority
rights unimpaired.
Findings: The Board has jurisdiction by reason of the parties
Agreement establishing this Board.
Claimant Trackman, on February 27, 1987, was working on
Tie gang 5012 in the vicinity of Ozark, Arkansas. He was
arrested by Ozark Police Officer at 4:15 AM on February 26,
1987 on the charges that (1) he failed to maintain control
of his vehicle; (2) DWI; (3) possession of marijuana.
Claimant was booked on the criminal information and
bound over to the Franklin County Jail. Prior to
incarceration, a blood-alcohol test was administered and the
test results reflected .11.
Claimant later made bond of $786 and was released at
4:00 PM. He was ordered to appear in the Ozark Courthouse
on March 11 at 9:00 AM at which time he pled guilty to all
three charges. The Claimant was referred to the Western
Arkansas Counseling and Guidance Center.
As a result of the above Claimant was required to
attend a formal investigation on those charges involving
"possession, driving while intoxicated and possession of
marijuana while operating a motor vehicle... Resulting in
conduct unbecoming an employee."
Carrier concluded from the transcript thereof that
Claimant was culpable of these charges, that the charges had
been sustained and that the Claimant had specifically
violated Article 5 of the Conditions of Employment.
Claimant was dismissed from service as discipline therefor.
-2- Award No. 327
Consistent with their policy Claimant was sent a letter
by the Employee Assistance Program Director and he responded
affirmatively to the offer to enter the EAP program. He
continued in said program but quit in the Fall of 1987 on
the basis that he chose to progress his reinstatement pay
for time lost claim to arbitration. The program authorities
therefore closed his file due to "inactivity."
There is nothing to review in this record. Clearly the
Claimant was given the due process to which entitled under
his rule. That the incident occurred outside of working
hours and off Carrier's property does not change the
conclusion reached in this particular case. This is found
to be particularly true in view of Item 5 of the Conditions
of Employment. If an employee's misconduct while off duty
and off Carrier's property has a deleterious effect on the
employee/employer relationship or on the employer's
relationship with its customers, or the communities through
which it operates then such misconduct is punishable. See
as an example of support therefor Third Division Award 893,
Award No. 5105, and Award 19263.
There was sufficient, competent and probative
evidence, including the Arkansas Arrest/Deposition Report,
prepared by the Ozark Police Department, also the results of
Claimant's court appearance on March 7th and his admissions
thereat, serve to void the necessity of any further review
of the record to support conclusions of guilt.
Notwithstanding, the Board does find cause in the
record to conditionally reinstate Claimant to service
with all rights unimpaired but without pay for time out of
service. Such conditional reinstatement is subject to and
providing that Claimant does report to, enters into
Carrier's Employee Assistant Program and he receives a
clearance from the Carrier's Employee Assistance Program
counselors within thirty days of notification of this offer
of conditional leniency. If the Claimant fails to
affirmatively comply therewith within thirty days of such
notification the claim will be denied as of that time.
Award: Claim disposed of as per findings.
Order: Carrier is directed to make this Award effective within
thirty (3 ) days of date of issuance shown below.
S. ammons, 'Jr.Ir p'oyee Member J hannon, Carrier Member
Arthur T. Van Wart, hairman
and Neutral Member
Issued July 13, 1989.