SPECIAL BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT N0. 279
Award No. 426
Docket No. 426
File 890254
Parties Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes
to and
Dispute Union Pacific Railroad Company
(Former Missouri Pacific Railroad Company)
Statement
of Claim: (1) Carrier violated the Agreement, especially Rule 2, when
Leon H. Robinson was not allowed to displace M. J. Currans
within the expiration of his twenty days.
(2) Claim in behalf of Mr. Robinson for eight (8) hours each
work day, including overtime and holidays beginning November
29, 1988 and continuing.
Findings: The Board has jurisdiction of this case by reason of the
parties Agreement establishing this Board therefor.
The Claimant Track Foreman, Leon H. Robinson, was
bumped by a senior employee on November 28, 1988. Robinson
attempted to bump a junior employee, Foreman M. J. Currans,
who had been furloughed and who was working the temporary
vacancy of assigned Foreman T. L. Robinson, who was absent
due to sickness, at Engleton, Texas.
The pertinent Agreement provisions read:
"Rule 11 - Bulletin
(a) New positions and vacancies will be advertised promptly
and in any case no later than ten (10) days following the
establishment of the position or the date the vacancy
occurs. yT em orar vacancies created by reason of
a
-regular
assigned employee's absence due to sickness or injury, or
authorized leave of absence when known to be of twenty (20)
days or more duration will, if the vacancy is to be filled,
be advertised and assigned as 'temporary vacancies.'..
Employees assigned to temporary vacancies will be subject to
displacement by senior employees who have displacement
rights..." (emphasis added)
Rule 2 - Seniority Rights, reads:
"(f) Employees entitled to exercise seniority rights over
junior regular assigned employees must designate exercise of
such rights within twenty (20) calendar days following their
displacement or their return to service... Otherwise,
employees who fail to exercise seniority rights within the
twenty (20) calendar days specified herein, shall forfeit
their ri ht to dis lace a regular assigned em to ee and
shall take their pace on the furloughed with
preference to work over the junior employees thereon and
will be subject to bulletined positions _in line with their
seniority.
(g) Foreman ...who are subject to the provisions of this
Agreement after having exhausted their rights in the class
in which employes, shall have the right to drop back to the
next lower classification in line with their seniority and
that classification.
(h) An employee who returns to a lower classification and
retains seniority in a higher classification as provided in
(g)...may if he so desires waive the right to work extra or
temporary vacancies other than assignment by bulletin per
Rule 12..."
When the facts are applied to the rules involved it
would appear that the claim has no merit. Claimant had no
contractual right to displace M. J. Currans who was working
the position of T. L. Robinson as an extra while it was
being advertised. Leon Robinson, if he were senior, could
have displaced the owner of the position, T. L. Robinson,
who was off sick. Notwithstanding, there were two "regular"
assigned employees that he could have bumped, Manual Canto,
Jr. on Gang 2806, or D. R. Rodriduez, on Gang 2888, both of
whom were junior to him. This claim will be denied.
Award: Claim denied.
aa %P~
S. . Hammons, Jr., Em oyee Member D. A. Ring, Carri r tuber
Arthur T. Van Wart, C afrnfan
and Neutral Member
Issued November 26, 1990.