SPECIAL BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT N0. 279
Award No. 493
Case No. 493
File 900453
Parties Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes
to and
Dispute Union Pacific Railroad Company
(Former Missouri Pacific Railroad
Statement
of Claim: Claim on behalf of Trackman D. L. Maxwell, SSN 446-64-4195,
who was dismissed account of illegal or unauthorized drugs,
as evidenced by the positive test results of the reasonable
cause drug and alcohol test given him April 10, 1990, at
Muskogee, Oklahoma, in violation of Rules B and G of Form
7908.
Findings: The Board has jurisdiction of this case by reason of the
parties Agreement establishing this Board therefor.
The Claimant was notified to attend a formal
investigation on the charge:
"...that you allegedly used an illegal or unauthorized
drug as evidenced by the positive test result of the
reasonable cause drug and alcohol test given you, in
accordance with the Union Pacific Railroad Drug and
Alcohol Policy and Procedures effective January 16,
1990, on April 10, 1990 at Muscogee, Oklahoma..."
The Carrier concluded him culpable therefrom. He was
dismissed from service as discipline therefor.
The Claimant was one of the Mofld Employes who were
called back to work for the purposes of "taking up." The
gang had been put back to work about January 2, 1990.
Claimant was injured on January 25, 1990 and was
hospitalized for a hernia which he had suffered off duty but
re-injured while on duty. The Claimant was told that he had
to be off for six weeks. When the Carrier went looking for
the Claimant, they discovered that he was in a
rehabilitation center at Cushing, Oklahoma. Carrier's EAP
investigator said that while they had worked with the
Claimant on two other occasions he had failed to finish his
program with them. The EAP thought that the Claimant had
been removed from service about October 18, 1988.
The record shows that the Claimant was asked to leave
the rehabilitation
center at Cushing for having been on
drugs while in the treatment center. That fact caused
Carrier to decide that they should require a drug test of
the Claimant before permitting him to return to work. The
test was given and the Claimant tested positive.
The record supports there was a sufficiency of evidence
to support Carrier's conclusion as to the Claimant's
culpability.
In light of the offense, and particularly Claimant's
previous two dismissals, this discipline is deemed
reasonable. This claim will be denied.
Award: Claim denied.
-i ~r gyp.
~- ~,~.'.
S. A. Hammons, Jr., Employee Member D. A. Ring, Carri r mber
Arthur T. Van W rt, Chairman
and Neutral Member
Issued October 26, 1991.