SPECIAL BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT N0. 279
Award No. 601
Docket No. 601
U.P. File No. 920493
Parties Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes
to and
Dispute Union Pacific Railroad Company
(Former Missouri Pacific)
Statement
of Claim: (1) Carrier violated the Agreement, especially Rule 12,
J. Fuentes (SSN 459-78-6287) was dismissed from service on
July 21, 1992.
(2) Claim in behalf of Mr. Fuentes for wage loss suffered
beginning June 23, 1992, until reinstated with seniority,
vacation and all other rights unimpaired.
Findings: The Board has jurisdiction by reason of the parties
Agreement establishing this Board therefor.
The Claimant J. Fuentes, Jr. a B&B Carpenter, with some
20 years service, following a personal formal investigation
held in absentia on July 13, 1992, on the charge:
" ..you failed to comply with verbal instructions of Manager
Bridge Maintenance David Bateman and failed to comply with
instructions as contained in his letter of April 30, 1992,
May 14, 1992, and June 15, 1992, when you failed to report
for physical examination on May 8, 1992 and May 21, 1992 and
June 23, 1992 respectively, in Dr. Robert Goff's office..."
As a result, the Carrier concluded the Claimant
culpable of the charge. He was dismissed from service as
discipline therefor.
Claimant was accorded the due process to which entitled
under Rule 12.
There was sufficient evidence adduced to support
Carrier's conclusion as to the Claimant's culpability. The
record is clear that the Claimant did not act in a normal
manner and that the Carrier had elected to send the Claimant
for a physical examination to ascertain the reason therefor.
The Claimant has many years of long service. He was
well thought of by the Carrier representatives and many of
his fellow employees. It was their concern for his safety
that caused the Carrier on April 30, May 8, 14, to send
certified letters to the Claimant to report for a doctor's
appointment on specified dates. The several letters were
sent back unclaimed. The Claimant failed to keep his
appointments. Further, on June 15, 1992, following a safety
meeting the Claimant was advised by Manager of Bridge
Maintenance Bateman that an appointment had been made for
him at 11:15 on June 23. The Claimant was given a copy of
the letter which he signed for. He again failed to keep the
appointment. It was later determined that the Claimant the
day before the appointment had cancelled his appointment on
the basis that he had car trouble.
The Board finds that the Carrier has the authority when
there is concern for an employee's physical or mental
condition to take affirmative action to send such employee
for a physical examination for a medical evaluation.
The Claimant has failed to act in other than an
aberrant manner.
The Board is willing to conditionally reinstate the
Claimant on a last chance basis without any pay for time out
of service providing that he makes the decision to go for a
physical including mental and, if necessary, an-EAP
evaluation. When 30 days has elapsed from notice of this
offer, it shall be presumed that the Claimant has no
interest therein. A denial award shall then become final as
of that date.
Award: Claim disposed of as per findings.
Order: Carrier is directed to make this Award effective within
thirty (30) days of date of issuance shown below.
a~c~ra.~r-r..e~wo~.
S. A. ammons, Jr., Employee Member Kathy Ilexandei, Carrier Member
A thur T. Van Wart, Chairman
and Neutral Member
Issued
November 27, 1993.