SPECIAL BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT N0. 280
Award No. 143
Case No. 228
PARTIES St. Louis Southwestern Railway Company -
TO and -
DISPUTE Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employees
STATEMENT "Claim of the System Committee that:
of CLAIM
1. Carrier violated the effective Agreement when Extra Gang Laborer
Joe D. Johnson was dismissed without just and sufficient cause on
March 3, 1977.
2. Claimant ice 0. Johnson be reinstated to his former position with
pay for all time lost and with all seniority, vacation and other
rights restored. Also, that his record be cleared of this charge."
FINDINGS -
t
Upon the whole record, after hearing, the Board finds that the parties herein are Car=
rier and Employees within the meaning of the Railway Labor Act, as amended, and that
this Board is duly constituted under Public Law 89-456 and has jurisdiction of the
parties and the subject matter.
Claimant herein, an Extra Gang Laborer, was discharged after being charged with engaging,
in an altercation with his foreman. Subsequently, he was granted an investigative hearing and the dismissal was reaffirmed following that hearing. .
A review of the transcript of the investigation in this dispute indicates that Claimant
had been involved in a dispute with his foreman on the-day in question and had been refusing to perform his duties as required by the foreman.. After being told by the foreman that he was dismissed as a result of the insubordinate acts, Claimant attacked the
foreman. He was later found by the Assistant Roadmaster to be holding the foreman down
on the ground in the course of the altercation. It is clear from the testimony including Claimant's own admission that he did indeed attack the foreman. Hence, the evidenc_
supports Carrier's determination that Claimant was guilty. Under the circumstances,
therefore, and in view of the nature of the infraction, Carrier's position must be upheld. Conduct such as that engaged in by Claimant herein is intolerable and need not b:
Award No. 143 $gp ZBO
-2-
condoned. The claim must be denied. '
AWARD
Claim denied.
7.M. Lieberman, Neutral Member
Carrier Member. Employee Member
October ~9 , 1979
Houston, Texas