PARTIES TO DISPUTE:

 Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes ) Case No. 51
 and Award No. 51
 St. Louis Southwestern Railway Company
 STATEMENT OF CLAIM :
 1. The Carrier violated the effective Agreement by assigning the Machine Operator of the Kalamazoo Jack Tamper, namely J. M. Short, to the starting time of 12:00 noon on April 18, 1960, and continuing thereafter.

 2. The Carrier shall now compensate Claimant Machine Operator J. M. Short at the time and one-half rate of his position for the hours of service rendered by him between 12:00 noon and 3:00 p.m., and shall further compensate him for eight hours at his straight-time rate beginning at 3:00 p.m., less compensation already paid for such service beginning with the first work day of this new assignment of April 18, 1960,and continuing until this violation of the Agreement is ceased.

 FINDINGS :
 Upon the whole record and all the evidence, after hearing, the Board finds that the parties herein are carrier and employee within the meaning of the Railway labor Act, as amended, and that this Board is duly constituted by agreement and has ,jurisdiction of the parties and of the subject matter.

 For the reasons set forth in the Findings stated in Case No. 49 resulting in Award No. 49 this claim is denied.

 AWARD : Claim denied.


(Signed) A. J. Cunningham (Dissenting)
 A. J. Cunningham, Employee Member Signed) M. L. Erwin
 M. L. Erwin, Carrier Member
 Dated at Tyler, Texas (Concurring opinion attached)
 December 14, 1964

CONCURRING OPINION OF CARRIER MEMBER

AWARDS 9, 50, 51, 52, 53, 5., 59·


I concur in the decision that the restrictions relating to single shift operations did not apply under the conditions existing in these cases and that the claims should be denied, but it is my understanding the limitations in the rule apply only to single shift operations and that the carrier is not restricted as to starting time when two or more shifts are established, as in these cases.

                            Signed) M. L. Erwin

                            M. L. Erwin, Carrier Member