THE ORDER OF RAILROAD TELEGRAPHERS )
 vs )
 NEW YORK CENTRAL RAILROAD, EASTERN DISTRICT )
 (except Boston and Albany Division) and )
 NEW YORK DISTRICT )




























          (apjoesxo0 Is leAZaav sTil Bulaaodax soddoa ao$onpuo3 ao3) IaqzeH 'M '3


      :aIasuadmoa o:j paaTnbaz aq lleqs aaTs.zeO 'suoTasIOTA asaq4 3o quanbasuoo u= ·Z


°6ouasaama ue UT IOU °aTxoasxo0 IV ZII puE OTI *ON
 saapao uTsay Adoo of pue aTnoesxo0 6q T-Ad uTezl laodaa o3 1-7, -M loplovsxoD IV
 zeaIO aq4 UT set uTas:l sTq amT:l aq:i pue TvAlzae sTq lzodaz o:j sauamaazSy aq:t !q
 paaaAoo 4ou aAoldma aoTA.zas UTL-11 a Iddoa ·r ·V aolonpuoo pazTnbaa IT `0961 `SI
 qa;xaN uo uaqM :juamaaaBV ssaaqds:E8alay aq:1 ;o ZZ pus I sal7ijxV paIeIOTA zalaas0 'I

                                                :6 'ON asa0


    'pTesaxoJs uoT4eTOTA ay4 xo; anoq aad 86£'Z$ IV sanoq (8) Asp auo zo; `0967 `6

qoxzN uo aAoldma saixa alpT aoTuas aya l4uag ·H ·g ^szN alesuadmoo ITaqs aatzxe0 'Z

 ^AOUq2aama ue UT IOU ' °X, °N
 °aPiossxo3 as 911 'OR aapzp uTszy (zaATTap pue Ado:) 'aATaoaa) alpueq o: ":Iuamaaz2y
 aqq Aq pazaAoo IOU aAoldma aoTAZas uTeaj a Iddoa ao4anpuoo paaTnbaa IT `0961 `6
 q*xeK uo uaqM 'auamaasSV esaaqdeaSaIay aq:i 3o ZZ pue I saloTa:xV pa:jeToTA zazaae0 ^I

                                                :8 -ON asa0


'pTssazoJs uozI
 -aIoTA aqj so; anoq sad +~8+7=Z$ ;o aqez aq:t IV 'sanoq (8) 'Asp auo zo3 `0961 `8
 qozeyq uo aAOTdma aa:Ixa alpl zoTuas aq:t aAIlauuoQ ·r ^g aissuadmoo IIsqs saTasaO °Z

    °6auaqzama us uT IOU °°7, 'N `auaASg

    IV 011 -ON aapzo uTaay (xaATTap pue Adoo °aATaoaz) alpueq oa °quamaazBV aq:t .Aq

    pazaAoo IOU aAoIdma a3ZAaaS UTaaa a sioonjzaqTz aolonpuoo pazTnbaz 11 `0961 `8

qaaeN uo luaqm juamaax2y ~saaqdeadaTay aqa ;o ZZ pus I sa1oT3ay paIeIOTA zaTazs0 'I

                                                :e 'ON ase0


    ^pTzsazo;s

    uoTieToTA siq3 .xo3 :Enoq zad 86VZt :1e esanoq qq$Ta (8) °Aap DUO 103 6T yoZxeN

    uo aAOTdma azlxa salpT 'xoTuas agl `a2pTaqmoxz ·M °0 aqesuadmoo lleqs aaTxzeO °Z


    ^louaszema uu UT IOU 1^A ^N 'aTxaesxo0

    Is VOT -ON aapao uiszy (zaATTap pue Adoo saATaoaz) alpusq of eauamaas2y sip Aq

    paaaAOO IOU aioTdma aalAxas uzea:j a 'ddoQ -r ^H ao3onpuoo paslnbaz aI `0961 `I

qaaeN uo suaqm quamaaa3V esaaqdsx9aIay aqj 3o ZZ pue I saIDTIaV P93VTOTA zalaze0 ^I

                                                :9 -ON ase0


                                        ^pTssaaoge uoTIeIOTA aqq

:cog .xnoq ;E-ad 868^Z$ 3o DIVA aqI ;e ls;Enoq IqSTa (8) sXap Duo zo3 `0961 `9Z A;tEns
 -qai[ uo aAoIdma s.zixa alpl 30IuaS aq:j °auTasnSnV -r °r aIasuadmoa TIsqs zaTzaaO ·Z

    ^.Couasaama us UT IOU °°,I °N °aixossxo0 3e ITT

    'ON xapzO UTaay (zaATIap pus Adoo °aniaoaa) alpueq oI °auamaaa2y aqq Aq pazaAoo

    zou.aAoIdma aoTAaas ulezq s epusTzaSuTTg ,xolonpuoo pazTnbaz IT `0967 `9Z Xavnz

    -qa,3 uo uaqM 'auamaaz2y eszaqdaaSalay aqp 3o ZZ pue I salpl-4zy pa:tETo'Fn ?aTzzeO 'I


                                                :5 -ON ese0


6 'ON assp
 6 *ON allVMV
 I2h 'VIRS
                                                S8.4

                                                ANARD NO. 9 Case No. 9


    R. J. Donnelly (for Conductor Dopp reporting his train into clear)


    S. J. Buboltz (for Conductor Dopp reporting Train PV-1 by Coxsackie)


    F. H. Kent (for Conductor Dopp copying Train Order No. 110)


    senior idel extra employes on March 15, 1960, for one day (8) eight hours each at the. rate of $2.398 per hour, and Carrier shall also be required to compensate M. F. Haggerty, the senior employe,on his rest day,, March 15, 1960, for one day (8) eight hours (for Conductor Dopp copying Train Order No. 112) at the rate of $2.398 per hour, for the five violations aforesaid.


    Case No. 10:


    1. Carrier violated. Articles 1 and 22 of the Telegraphers' Agreement, when on March 21, 1960, it required Conductor R. L. Smith, a train service employe not covered by the Agreement, to handle (receive, copy and deliver) Train Orders No. 108 and 111 at Catskill, N. Y.


    2. In consequence of these violations, Carrier shall be required to compensate S'. J. Buboltz (for Order 1108) and F. W. Hartel (for order iklll), the senior idle employes on March 21, 1960, for one day (8) eight hours each at the rate of $2.428 per hour for, the violations aforesaid.


    Case No. 11:


    1. Carrier violated Articles 1 and 22 of the Telegraphers' Agreement, when on March 22, 1960, it required Conductor Dopp, a train service employe not covered by the Agreement, to handle (receive, copy and deliver) Train Order No. 107 at Coxsackie, N. Y., not in an emergency.


    2. In consequence of this violation, Carrier shall be required to compensate F. W. Hartel, the senior idle extra employe on March 22, 1960, for one day (8) eight hours at the rate of $2.398 per hour for the violation aforesaid.


    Case No. 12:


1. Carrier violated Articles 1 of the Telegraphers' Agreement when on March 21, 1960,
 it required Conductor Dopp, Train VT-2 to clear his train at Coxsackie, N.Y.,
 to report time cleared and to report Train PV-1 by him at Coxsackie, N. Y.

    2. Carrier violated Article 1 of the Telegraphers Agreement when, on March 22, 1960, it required Conductor Dopp, Train VT-2 to clear his train at Coxsackie, N. Y.,to report time cleared and to report Train PV-1 by him at Coxsackie, N. Y.


    3. In consequence of these violations, Carrier shall be required to pay G. W. Trowbridge for 8 hours at the rate of $2.398 per hour for the violation on March 22, 1960. G. W. Trowbridge was the senior idle extra employe on that date, and shall be required to pay R. J. Donnelly, the senior idle extra employe on March 21, 1960, for 8 hours at the rate of $2.398 per hour for the violation of March 21, 1960.

                                                sat ~l

    AWARD N0. 9 Case No. 9 Case No. 13:


    1. Carrier violated the Scope Rule of the Telegraphers' Agreement when on April 27, 1960, it required Conductor Richter, a train service employe not covered'by the' Agreement, to report the time Extra 8552 west was into clear at Catskill, N. Y., not in an emergency.

2. In consequence of this violation, Carrier shall be required to compensate F. W.
 Hartel, the senior idle extra employe on April 27, 1960, for one day (8) hours
 at the rate of $2.428 per hour for the violation aforesaid.
 OPINION OF BOARD:
 The evidence establishes that the Agreement violations charged in each of the in
 stances cited above did, in fact, occur. Part 1 of each of the foregoing cases must
 be sustained. In view of the special circumstances involved in all of these cases,
 however, the compensation requested for each instance will be denied.
 AWARD:
 Sustained in part and denied in part as stated in the above Opinion of Board.

                      /s/ Lloyd H. Bailer

                    Lloyd H. Bailer, Chairman


/s/ L. Faulds /s/ R. J. Woodman
 L. Faulds, Carrier Member R. J. Woodman, Employe Member

 New York, N. Y. July 23, 1962

                                              c~ p5196?'


                            _ 4 _