Award #5
Case #5
ORT #3082
SPECIAL BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT N0. 525
THE ORDER OF RAILROAD TELEGRAPHERS
VS.
THE DENVER AND RIO GRANDE WESTERN RAILROAD
STATEMENT OF CLAIM
:
1. The Carrier violated the Agreement between the parties
hereto, when effective at the close of shift on July 22,
1959, it improperly declared abolished the Agent's position at Trinidad, Colorado, without in fact abolishing
the work thereof, and thereafter required employees not
covered by said Agreement to perform the work of the purportedly abolished position.
2. a) The Carrier shall, because of the violation set out
above, restore L. J. Stuart, the regularly assigned Agent
at Trinidad at the time of its purported abolishment to
the position, from which he was improperly removed, and,
b) Compensate L. J. Stuart, for any wage loss and expenses incurred by reason of said improper abolishment,
and
3. The Carrier shall, in addition to the foregoing, compensate each and every employee who was displaced from his
position as a result of the Carrier's violative act, an
amount equivalent to that which the employee would have
earned on his position, in addition to expenses incurred
by reason of said abolishment, and
4. The Carrier shall, in lieu of Item 3, pay to the senior
idle telegrapher, extra in preference, a day's pay at the
rate of the purportedly abolished position on such day
or days on which Claimant L. J. Stuart suffers no monetary loss directly attributable to the Carrier's violative
act.
FILINGS
This Board, upon the whole record and all of the evidence, finds that:
The Carrier and the Employee and Employees involved in all of the dis-
putes involved in this docket of cases are respectively carrier and employee
· · Sri
R
sa ~ - .~-~ ~ 5
_2_
within the meaning of the Railway Labor Act, as approved June 21, 1934, and
as since amended.
This Board has jurisdiction over the disputes involved herein. The
parties to said disputes were given due notice of hearing thereon.
SPECIFIC FINDINGS:
During the prolonged steel strike in 1959, Carrier obtained permission
of the State Public Utilities Commission to close its agency at Trinidad, tem
porarily. It was re-opened four months later. The evidence shows that all agency
work was transferred to Telegraph Agent at Walsenburg during the shutdown. Such
work as remained was not substantial and the Carrier was within its rights in
temporarily abolishing the position. The collection of cartage revenue is not
exclusive work of a Telegrapher, although previously done by him.
AWARD
Claims denied.
/s/ J. Glenn Donaldson
J. Glenn Donaldson, Neutral Member
Chairman
/s/ R. K. Anthis
R. K. Anthisa Organization Member°-
/s/ J. W. Lovett
J. W. Lovett-, Carrier' Member -°
Denver, Colorado
November 20, 1963