SPECIAL BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT N0. 924
Award No. 12
Docket No. 12
PARTIES: Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes
TO
DISPUTE: Chicago and. North Western Transportation Company
STATEMENT OF CLAIM: Claim of the System Committee of the Brotherhood
that:
(1) The dismissal of Track Supervisor L. C. Lager for
alleged violation of Rule G and an accident with a
Company Vehicle was without just and sufficient
cause and excessive. (Organization File 2D-3677,
Carrier File 81-83-114-D).
(2) Track Supervisor L. C. Lager shall'be reinstated
with seniority and ell other rights unimpaired and
compensated for all wage loss suffered.
FINDINGS:
This Board, upon the whole record and all the evidence, finds
and holds that the employes and the Carrier involved, are respectively
employes and, Carrier within the meaning of the Railway Labor Act, as
amended, and that the Board has jurisdiction over the dispute herein.
Claimant, with about twelve years of service, was employed by
the Carrier as a Track S,ipervisor on the .Trenton Sub-Division. The
OrFanization states that his assignment required him to be away from
his headquarters on two days, necessitating his staying in a motel
and taking his meals out of restaurants. On March 1, 1983, claimant
was notified to appear for formal investigation at P:00 P.M., March
7, 1983, on the charge:
"Your responsibility in connection -ith violation of
&nle G at ebout 10:30 FM Feb. 2f, 1983, while operating
Company Vehicle 21-3458 at Excelsior Springs, Mo., outside of your regular tour of duty hours and-
Your resuonsibility in connection with Accident with
Company Vehicle Unit 21-3458, and another privately
owned vehicle, in Excelsior Springs, Mo. about 7:00 AM,
March 1, 1983."
The investigation was postponed and conducted on March 8, 1983.
Rule G of Carrier's General Regulations and Safety Rules, as
read into the investigation by the conducting officer, provides:
s& /)- 9aY
Award No. 12
Docket No. 12
Page
2.
"The use of alcoholic beverages or narcotics by employees subject to duty is prohibited. Being under
the influence of alcoholic beveraaes or narcotics
while on duty or on Company property is urohibited.
The use or possession of alcoholic beveraxes or narcotics while on duty or on Company property is prohibited."
In the investigation it was developed, and claimant admitted,
that following the completion of his regular tour of duty on
February
28, 1983,
claimant drove a Company truck, identified as
Vehicle
21-3458,
to an Excelsior Springs bar, then went to other
Excelsior Springs bars where he consumed intoxicants, until about
10:30
P.M. when he was arrested, given a breathslizer test, which
indicated an alcohol test of .15, while under the Missouri law
a test of .10 indicates intoxication. Claimant was charged by
the police with three moving violations and driving while intoxicated. He was released on bond at about
3:00
A.M. On the following morning, after retrieving the Company vehicle, claimant was
involved' in an accident at a McDonelds parking lot about 7:00 A.M.,
left the scene of the accident, and subseauently Excelsior Springs
police contacted the Carrier to ascertain the identity and whereabouts of the operator of the vehicle, which ledto Carrier's
knowledge of the incidents involved and the cher7e of March 1,
1983.
The record shows that throughout the handling claimant was
cooperative with the Police of Excelsior Springs, with Carrier's
Special Agent, and in the investigation crnducted on March
8, 1983.
Claimant, in answer to the question: "Do you feel like you complied with Rule G on February
28, 1983?"
claimant responded "No,
I did not:" Claimant went on to state that he had a drinking
problem "and I am seeking help and I am just sorry it took so long
to find out..."
Claimant was dismissed from service on March 11,
1983.
We
agree that extreme discipline was warranted. We note, however,
that the record contains a report from Shawnee Mission Medical
Center, dated July 11,
1983,
repdine in part:
"Mr. Lager entered the Shawnee Mission Medical Center
Alcoholism Recovery Unit on March
15, 1983.
The program
consists of a minimum
21
days as inpatient treatment for
the disease of sleoholism. Mr. Lager completed
21
days
on April
5, 7.983,
at which time he was discherged with
the recommenrlation that he become active in Alcoholics
Anonymous (AA) in the community."
,sm-
9a y
Award No. 12
Docket No. 12
Page
3.
Considering~claimant's cooperation throughout the handling
of the entire affair, and his apparent efforts to correct his
drinking problem, we are not convinced that the ultimate industrial
penalty of permanent dismissal was warranted. The time that claimant
has been out of the service should constitute sufficient discipline.
We will award that claimant be restored to service with seniority
and other rights unimpaired, but without any compensation for any
time lost while out of the service. We admonish claimant, however,
that he must conduct himself in a satisfftctory manner in the future
and that further-major infractions on his part-will receive short'
shrift by all concerned.
A
.W
A H D
Claim sustained to the extent indicated in Findings.
ORDER
The Carrier is directed to comply with this Award within
thirty days from the date hereof.
Chairman, Neutral Membe
r
J~ _ _
Labor .ember
Ihm le
DATED:? - lJ ·Q