SPECIAL BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT N0. 924
Award No. 3
Docket No. 3
PARTIES:: Btrotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes
TO :=
DISPUTE:. Chicago and North Western Transportation Company
STATEMENT OF CLAIM-:_"Claim of the System Committee of the Brotherhood
that::
(1). The dismissal of F. A. W9ltha for alleged unauthorized
possession of Company property and bri Ing discredit to
the Company at Denison, Iowa, on July
21,
1982, was without just and sufficient cause and on the basis. of disproven and unproven-charges. (Organization File 4.D-3216;,
Carrier File D-11-3-368).
(:2) Claimant F-: A. Weltha shall be reinstatedwith seniority
and all other rights unimpaired and compensated for all'
wage loss suffered."
FINDINGS:.
The Beard, upon-the whole record and all the evidence, finds
and holds that the employes and the Carrier-involved, are respectively
employes and Carrier within the meaning of the Railway LabbP Act, asamended, and that the Bbard has jurisdiction over the dispute=herein:
Claimant was employed as a trackman in Tie Gang--713, which
was to begin work at Denison; Iowa, on July 26, 1982. Claimant, upon
reporting for duty, parked his vehicle on a city street and walked
to the depot _which was the gang's starting point. The claimant was
informed that Carrier's Special Agents and Denison Police Department
representatives,.with a specially trained Police dog, were investigating employes for possible drug use or possession.
A'search of claimant's vehicle by Dentson'-Police Department
representatives, revealed whatthe Carrier describes as "processed
marijuna, Hashish, several containers with Cocaine residue, and
Company property consisting of four pairs of safety glasses and a
caboose cushion." As his vehicle was not parked on Company property,
he was not chargedwith possession of marijuana or controlled substances
on Company property. However, hewas arrested by Denison Police Department representatives and his vehicle was impounded. As an article
appeared°innthe Denison Bulletin; a daily newspaper-of general distribution in the area, stating that claimant had been charged with
possession of marijuana and identifying him·as a Chicago and North
Western employe, he was charged on July 28, 1982:
Award.'No.
3
' Docket Nb-
3
page: 2.
"Tour, responsibility in connection with::
1. Unauthorized possession of Company property
in your- personal vehicle at Denison, Iowa on
July 26, 1982.
2': &ringing·discredit to the Company at Denison,
Iowa on July 26, 1982."
The-investigation was scheduled ror and held on August 4,
1982, following which claimant was dismissed,~from service. A.copy
of.-the transcxipt'-of the-investigation has been made a part of the
record. A'review of same shows that the investigation was conducted
in a fair and impartial manner--
Rule 7 of.`Carrier's<Ceneral Regulations and Safety Rules
reads:.
"Employes are prohibited from being careless of the-,
safety of themselves or others, disloyal, insubordinate,
dishonest, immoral, quarrelsome or otherwise.. vicious or,
conducting themselves in such a manner that the railroad`
will be subjected to criticism and loss of good will, or~-
not`meeting their personal obligations."There was substantial evidence introduced at the investigation to support the charges against the claimant. Re contended
that he had found--the caboose cushion, but he did not remembers
telling any official of having-fbund it, or of being in possession
of four pairs of safety glasses: In the investigation he attempted
to account for two pairs of the glasses, b'ut the other.-two pairs
were not accounted for. His statements in this respect are not
persuasive.
The Carrier advises that with regard.to the criminal
charges against the claimant, he pleaded guilty to the possession
of a controlled substance and was-fine&$110.00 and costs.
Hawed upon the entire record, the Hoard does not find theCarrierts action to be arbitrary, capricious, or in bad faith.
The claim will'-be denied`.
A W A E TJ'
Claim denied,:
ai~Neutr
r~
L.
rrier Member-Labor 1vlembe .
DATE:
- 2 l c
~
3