Special Board of Adjustment No. 956
PARTIES Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes
TO
DICPDTE;
and
New Jersey Transit Rail Operations, Inc.
STATEMENT Claim of the Brotherhood:
OF
CLAIM The dismissal of Claimant S. Davis was in violation of
the Agreement, particularly Rule 27 of the collective
bargaining agreement. The Claimant shall be reinstated
without loss of compensation, including overtime, and
without loss of seniority and vacation rights and any
other benefits enjoyed by Claimant prior to dismissal.
FINDINGS Carrier maintains that Claimant forfeited all seniority
by violating Rule 27(b). .Rule 27(b) reads as follows:
"Except for sickness or disability, or under
circumstances beyond his control, an employee who is
absent in excess of fourteen (14) consecutive days
without receiving permission from his supervisor
will forfeit all seniority under this Agreement.
The employee and the General Chairman will be
furnished a letter notifying them of such forfeiture
of seniority. The employee or his representative
may appeal from such action under Rule 26, Section
3."
The record establishes that Claimant was absent in excess of 14
days.
95 6 - v9
-2-
While the Organization has presented a doctor's notice of the
Claimant's illness, such notice does not show that the Claimant was
unable to comply with Rule 27 (b) as a result of this illness, nor did
it give ample reason why the Claimant did not notify his supervisor of
his infirmity. Therefore, the organization's position that this case
is within the parameters of the exceptions given in Rule 27(b) is in
error.
It may well be that on some alleged date the Claimant notified
Mr. Diana in the Track Supervisor's office. However, the Carrier has
stated clearly that Mr. Diana denies ever having received such
information. No further proof was furnished by either the Claimant or
the organization; therefore, there does not exist any substantial
proof that the Claimant complied with the provisions of Rule 27(b).
Rule 27(b), as its terms expressly indicate, is a self-executing
provision that calls for forfeiture of all seniority. This Board has
no authority to modify the language that both parties have agreed to
'in this Rule.
AWARD: Claim denied.
Adopted at Newar Ni
' `s ,ew Jersey, 19~
i
Harold F7. Weston, Chairman
Carrier Member Employee Member